Tuesday, 24 July 2007

...it takes a politician to understand one?

I've promised myself I would not join the debate about the plane crash in Brazil, after posting about it last week.

But today, once again I was astonished by claims made by the BBC and it was just pretty damn hard not to write about it.

What made me even angrier was the fact these news are nowhere to be seen on Brazilian news websites, what is a pity in my view, this should be broadcasted for everyone to know what the so-called govern-for-the-people is doing to the country!

The issue now is hundreds are turning to buses or cars as a resort to travel and I seriously think this is more dangerous in Brazil than any flight. Even with the risks. Sources tell us that in average, 30.000 (thirty-thousand) people die on the roads every year in Brazil (see the Brazilian source here). Let's remember there were 353 dead from the last two air accidents. And that is another thing the press keeps quiet about. I am afraid now bus companies will start trying to take on more than they can, and that's another tragedy waiting to happen.

 

Here is the BBC article, with my comments:

 

Brazil rejects outside air help  

Now, why on Earth Brazil would refuse that? Help should always be welcomed. Even more when there are lives on the line.

 

The head of Brazil's airport authority has dismissed calls for the country to accept foreign help to address concerns over its aviation system.

An international air traffic controllers group said foreign experts should intervene in the wake of the crash in Sao Paulo that killed 199.

I completely agree with it. Something must be very wrong for the country to have two huge crashes in less than a year. When you have people coming from abroad, it is international interest to intervene.

 

A radar outage worsened the air traffic crisis in the country over the weekend.

But Infraero head Jose Carlos Pereira said the proposal was just an attempt to intervene in Brazil's affairs.

And what is wrong with that? Its clear to me Brazil does not have the competence to sort out its own problems.

 

Efforts to return Sao Paulo's Congonhas airport to normal are meanwhile being hampered by heavy rain which caused a landslip near the main runway.

Yeap, this just shows it is all falling apart - quite literally now - and how "efficiently" people responsible for running Brazil air control are taking care of the situation.

 

The head of the International Federation of Air Traffic Controllers' Associations, Marc Baumgartner, said on Monday that Brazil should bring in foreign experts to oversee its aviation system.

He said the Brazilian authorities were trying to save face following the crash at Congonhas and accused them of putting the travelling public at risk.

"We think they need an independent view," he told Reuters news agency. "It has the advantage of being neutral and it has worked before in other countries facing aviation crises."

He is so right, I can't put it into words. This is exactly what is happening. It is known fact by now the whole issue with air traffic started after it was demilitarized and became another place for nepotism and corruption. The last thing they want is someone independent and knows what they are doing to tell the whole nation what is wrong and how to fix that. It is disgusting how they put power and money over safety and life.

 

But his comments prompted a scathing response from the head of the national airport authority.

"They're a bunch of idiots wanting to intervene in our affairs," Jose Carlos Pereira told reporters.

"Brazil doesn't need international help. They should care for their air space and we'll take care of ours."

Typical ignorant Brazilian politician reply that is. This Jose Carlos Pereira should be put in jail for the last two accidents we had. No matter what reason, if the runaway was slippery, or the plane had problems, or was human fault from the pilot. This should all been identified and corrected before the crash. The runaway should not have been reopened, the plane should not be allowed to take off, and the pilot should have been better trained. There should be an organ to investigate, regulate and enforce what is right from wrong. The feel I have is they are treating air travel as good as road travel in Brazil. Terribly disorganized where anyone does what they want, when they want and how they want, under terribly maintained roads and along terrible drivers and dangerous vehicles.

 

Air travel in Brazil has been severely disrupted since last September, when a Boeing 737 clipped wings in mid-air with a private jet and crashed in the Amazon jungle, killing all 154 people on board.

And still, no one was blamed for that, and no action to avoid that in the future was taken, if not the contrary.

 

Flight delays and cancellations have become routine, as air traffic controllers, fearing they were being blamed for the accident, have staged periodic work slowdowns to protest at what they say they are bad radar and radio equipment and poor pay.

Who would not believe them? The poor situation they work under is being alerted for ages before the accident, but again, the press played dead.

 

On 18 July an Airbus A320 skidded off the wet runway at Sao Paolo airport and hit a cargo terminal and gas station, killing 199 people.

It was the deadliest air accident in Brazil's history.

 Lets hope is the last.

 

 

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

well... I'll take a chance to say: let's hope it was the worst one, the last, I'm not sure...